Eyes Right

long time lush user & always looked past this one, especially due to some of the poor reviews. decided to try for myself anyway & i have to say it did not disappoint. it is quite wet when applied but dries fast. it has held up ALL day & not crumbled at all. the wand is great & combs through my lashes so well, plus 0 clump-age! definitely water proof as well, i am blown away & will be buying this again.

So happy to be able to support such a great company with a daily staple. It took me a bit to get used to the applicator, but once I did, I get far better results with it than I have with any other. Very smooth mascara, lasts all day and looks great.

I use this mascara every day and it serves me very well. Very happy that it's ethical and not tested on animals. I wish it was sold in the glass containers again though, or anything other than plastic.

I wear fairly natural makeup 99% of the time (foundation, mascara, maybe some brown eye liner, a bit of blush...) and even I found this to be a preeeeetty minimalist mascara. It's quite a wet formula and doesn't appear to really build volume or length that much. I applied two coats of it and on the second go-round I didn't feel like it made too much of a difference. I had heard/read mediocre reviews on this one and decided to try it because I love what Lush stands for in terms of their cruelty free products, recyclable packaging (or packaging free!) and campaigning for important causes. I would love to see a glass bottle, maybe without a wand included so that you could just use a reusable mascara wand and only buy the makeup itself in the future. Bottom line, this will darken your natural lashes but it won't give you volume or length in the same way that other mascaras will. I didn't notice it flaking too much or transferring after about 6 hours of wear, but my test period was just around the house so could be slightly different if you're out and about. I'd love to see them tweak the formula a bit more.

It's impossible to make this look clumpy - I love the way it feels and it never feels sticky or heavy - just nourishing and softening. I'm a huge fan of the applicator brush and it's so much fun to put on. This mascara is a real pleasure and I'm so happy to have tried it. It's a very feel good mascara!! Not vavoom but if you want a subtle and beautifully natural feeling and looking mascara, this gave it to me!

I have sensitive eyes with astigmatism and loss of eyelashes and this is a MUST!

It doesn't have good coverage. It takes soooo long to dry and doesn't last long. I have panda eyes after a couple of hours. Oh man I wanted this to work sooooo much. One good thing is it doesn't sting my eyes at all.